Measuring What Matters in Peace Operations and Crisis Management
Sarah Jane Meharg
The first comprehensive overview of theories, mechanisms, and stakeholder approaches for measuring the success and progress of interventions within the global community of nations.
Queen's Policy Studies in partnership with Pearson Peacekeeping Centre
The international community has become increasingly interested in measuring the effectiveness of its activities in war-affected environments. This interest is partially motivated by a need to calculate the costs of these very expensive ventures and partially by the recognition that activities have not always been successful. While stakeholders are interested in measuring the effectiveness of their work in places like Afghanistan, they may be reticent to discover that their military, policing, and humanitarian activities are ineffectual or, worse, have had negative effects on recipient populations recovering from armed conflicts.
Sarah Jane Meharg analyses why various mechanisms - results-based management, measures of effectiveness, log frames, essential task matrices - are used in attempts to reduce complex intervention activities to simple success stories. She argues that the stakeholders involved could benefit from a deeper understanding of the theories, concepts, philosophies, and assumptions of other stakeholders in the peace operations and crisis management environment. She suggests ways to achieve this understanding through the strategic exercise of measuring effectiveness in relation to organizational requirements and recipient population’s priorities in post-conflict societies.
Measuring What Matters in Peace Operations and Crisis Management provides policy advice on stakeholder approaches and advances the thinking on measuring progress in general. Primary field research for this book was conducted by Canada's Pearson Peacekeeping Centre.
Review quotes
Measuring What Matters in Peace Operations and Crisis Management highlights the need to identify appropriate measures of effectiveness from the perspective of recipient populations so as to enable international actors to better comprehend the significance and impact of external interventions. This book is an important and timely contribution to the ongoing debate on the role of international actors in promoting peace and stability.
Martti Ahtisaari, Chairman, Crisis Management Initiative (2008 Nobel Peace Prize laureate)
Sarah Jane Meharg is senior research associate, Pearson Peacekeeping Centre, and adjunct assistant professor, Department of Politics and Economics, at the Royal Military College of Canada.